| The Rev. William Kellog |
1861 - 1862 |
| The Rev. H. C. Randall |
1863 - 1865 |
| The Rev. J. W. McIlevaine |
1866 - 1868 |
| The Rev. Edward Seymour |
1869 - 1873 |
| The Rev. James H. Bernard |
1873 - 1876 |
| The Rev. E. W. Flower |
1876 - 1878 |
| The Rev. Samuel French |
1879 - 1881 |
| The Rev. James L. Boxer |
1881 - 1884 |
| The Rev. John Trimble |
1884 - 1886 |
| The Rev. C. M. Pullen |
1886 - 1890 |
| The Rev. William R. Cross |
1890 - 1895 |
| The Rev. John E. Curzon |
1896 - 1910 |
| The Rev. William R. Cross |
1911 - 1923 |
| The Rev. Clark Attridge |
1923 - 1931 |
| The Rev. Hubert Cowley-Carroll |
1931 - 1933 |
| The Rev. Clarence Reimer |
1934 - 1940 |
| The Rev. William P. D. O’Leary |
1941 - 1951 |
| The Rev. E. G. Liebrecht |
1951 - 1953 |
| The Rev. Richard Trask |
1954 - 1956 |
| The Rev. Herman Page |
1957 - 1963 |
| The Rev. William Wiedrich |
1963 - 1971 |
| The Rev. Carlson Gerdau |
1971 - 1979 |
| The Rev. James Cardone |
1979 - 1982 |
| The Rev. Steven E. Powers |
1983 – 1999 |
| The Rev. Ted E. Durst |
2001 - 2004 |